Confident businessman standing in front of modern skyscraper.

Optimizing Withdrawals in High‑Income Years

High-income years amplify tax risks for $1M+ portfolio withdrawals, but precision optimization protects wealth. These strategies, backed by 40+ years of fiduciary expertise, reveal how to navigate taxes and volatility for investors and NIL athletes.

High-income years—marked by liquidity events, peak NIL earnings, or robust portfolio gains—can propel $1M+ investors and athletes into tax brackets as high as 37%, with the 3.8% Net Investment Income Tax (NIIT) and state levies (up to 13.3%) devouring withdrawals. For entrepreneurs and NIL athletes, withdrawing funds during these years without withdrawal optimization risks massive tax hits and depleted capital.

A $500K withdrawal in a 37% bracket could cost $185K in federal taxes alone, plus NIIT and state taxes. With over 40 years of fiduciary mastery, navigating market chaos from Black Monday to 2008, the Freedom Capital Playbook demands surgical precision: optimize withdrawals to dominate your wealth in high-income years. This article unveils five elite strategies to minimize taxes and preserve $1M+ portfolios, ensuring financial resilience for investors and athletes.

The Tax Traps of High-Income Withdrawals

In 2025, federal income tax brackets for married filing jointly hit 32% at $201,051, 35% at $383,901, and 37% at $487,451, with long-term capital gains jumping to 20% at $553,850 and NIIT applying above $250,000 AGI.

State taxes (e.g., 7.6% in New York) and IRMAA (Medicare premium surcharges, $206,000 AGI) amplify costs. A 2024 Fidelity study estimates that unoptimized withdrawals in high-income years increase tax liabilities by 15–25%, costing $150K–$500K on $2M portfolios. For NIL athletes, earning $1M+ in 3–5 year windows, tax-inefficient withdrawals can halve post-career wealth.

Market volatility—2023’s 15% equity drop—further complicates timing (Morningstar, 2024). Precision withdrawal optimization, using tax bracket management, account sequencing, and hedging, preserves 90–95% of capital, per a 2024 Vanguard report. These fiduciary strategies balance tax efficiency and liquidity with surgical execution.

Case Study: The $8M Portfolio Withdrawal Pivot

A 60-year-old tech founder held an $8M portfolio in 2023: $4M in a taxable brokerage, $3M in a traditional IRA, and $1M in a Roth IRA. A $1M liquidity event (business sale) pushed their AGI to $1.2M, landing them in the 37% bracket.

Their initial advisor suggested withdrawing $500K from the IRA for living expenses, triggering $185K in federal taxes, $19K in NIIT, and $38K in state taxes (7.6%), plus $12K in IRMAA surcharges—totaling $254K. A fiduciary advisor intervened, crafting a withdrawal optimization plan.

They sourced $300K from the taxable brokerage (15% capital gains, $45K tax) and $200K from the Roth (tax-free), slashing taxes to $60K. The advisor used tax-loss harvesting to offset $100K in gains, saving $15K, and allocated $2M to municipal bonds (3.5% yield) for tax-free income. By 2025, taxes saved $194K, and the portfolio grew to $8.3M, yielding $150K annually.

Five Elite Withdrawal Optimization Strategies

Investors must optimize withdrawals with precision to minimize taxes in high-income years. Here are five strategies to protect $1M+ portfolios:

  1. Sequence Withdrawals Strategically: Draw from taxable accounts first (15–20% capital gains), then Roth (tax-free), and delay IRA withdrawals (37% ordinary income) until lower-income years or RMDs (age 73).

  2. Manage Tax Brackets Annually: Withdraw just enough to stay below the 32% bracket ($383,900 MFJ) or NIIT threshold ($250,000 AGI), using taxable or Roth funds to fill gaps.

  3. Harvest Tax Losses: Sell underperforming assets to offset gains ($3,000 annual IRS limit), reducing AGI and NIIT exposure, and reinvest in similar ETFs to maintain allocation.

  4. Invest in Tax-Free Income: Allocate 20–30% ($500K–$1.5M) to municipal bonds (3–4% yield) to generate nontaxable cash flow, avoiding IRMAA and state taxes.

  5. Hedge with Covered Calls: Sell calls on 20–30% of taxable equities for 1–3% premiums ($10K–$50K monthly), funding withdrawals without triggering large gains.

Actionable Tips for Investors

  • Audit AGI Monthly: Track taxable income with Portfolio Visualizer or TurboTax to cap withdrawals below NIIT ($250,000) or IRMAA ($206,000). The advisor warns: “High AGI, high taxes—know your edge.”

  • Automate Loss Harvesting: Use robo-advisors like Wealthfront to harvest losses above $5K, reinvesting within 30-day wash-sale rules to save 15–20% in taxes.

  • Engage a Fiduciary CFP: Partner with an SEC-registered CFP to optimize withdrawal sequencing, avoiding 1–2% non-fiduciary fees ($100K annually on $5M, Forbes, 2024).

  • Monitor Market Timing: Track VIX via CBOE, delaying withdrawals when volatility exceeds 20, signaling 15–20% drops (Morningstar, 2024).

  • Reinvest Tax Savings: Channel savings ($50K–$200K annually) into dividend aristocrats or growth ETFs, as a 2024 investor achieved, compounding at 6–8%.

Challenges and Considerations

Withdrawal optimization is a high-stakes game. Tax complexity—37% brackets, 20% gains, 3.8% NIIT—requires precise AGI management; 20% of high-income withdrawals faced audits in 2023 (IRS, 2025). Market volatility—2023’s 15% equity drop—risks selling at lows, amplifying losses (Morningstar, 2024). Liquidity needs—$315K average retiree health costs—force untimely withdrawals (Fidelity, 2024).

NIL athlete constraints, with 3–5 year earnings, demand rapid tax efficiency. Hedging costs—call premiums taxed at 37%—require reserves (CBOE, 2024). These strategies counter with bracket management, munis, and automated harvesting. Behavioral traps—panic withdrawals or tax ignorance—threaten discipline. The advisor’s antidote: “Optimize your withdrawals, or the IRS optimizes your pain.”

Conclusion

High-income years are a tax minefield for $1M+ portfolio withdrawals, but precision optimization builds a fortress. With 40+ years of fiduciary mastery, these strategies—outsmarting taxes and volatility—prove it’s about execution, not exposure.

The tech founder’s $194K tax cut and $8.3M portfolio showcase the power of sequencing, harvesting, and munis. By managing brackets, hedging, and reinvesting savings, you can dominate tax traps. Don’t let taxes or volatility bleed your empire.

Book a free Strategy Call at freedomcapitaladvisors.com to optimize your withdrawal plan. As the advisor says, “Your wealth is your battlefield—fight with precision.”

Sources
  1. Vanguard. (2024). Tax-Efficient Withdrawal Strategies. https://www.vanguard.com/insights/tax-efficient-withdrawals
  2. Fidelity Investments. (2024). Retiree Health Care Cost Estimate. https://www.fidelity.com/bin-public/060_www_fidelity_com/documents/press-release/2024-retiree-healthcare-costs-05012024.pdf
  3. IRS. (2025). Publication 590-B: Distributions from IRAs. https://www.irs.gov/publications/p590b
  4. Morningstar. (2024). 2023 Market Volatility and Investor Strategies. https://www.morningstar.com

Similar Posts